Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles: Which Is Better for Minnesota Homes?

For Minnesota homeowners replacing a roof, metal and asphalt shingles are both serious
contenders. There isn't one correct material for every home—the best fit depends on your
building, priorities, and budget.

Asphalt shingles: familiar and versatile
Architectural shingles are widely available in many colors and styles. Their upfront cost is
usually lower than standing-seam metal, and experienced installers can handle complex
residential rooflines efficiently. Proper underlayment, flashing, ventilation, and fastening still
matter just as much as the shingles themselves.

Metal roofing: durable but detail-sensitive
Standing-seam metal can offer long service life and fewer exposed fasteners, while exposed-
fastener panels may have a lower upfront price but require periodic attention to screws and
washers. Metal expands and contracts as temperatures change, making panel design, clip
selection, penetrations, and flashing critical.

What about snow?
Snow can slide suddenly from certain metal roof surfaces, potentially creating hazards near
doors, sidewalks, decks, or landscaping. Snow retention devices may be appropriate depending
on the roof design. Asphalt shingles often hold snow differently, but both roof types must be
structurally designed for applicable snow loads.

Which roof costs more?
Material, labor, roof geometry, coatings, and accessories all affect the estimate. Instead of
comparing generic 'price per square' quotes, compare complete systems, maintenance
expectations, and realistic warranties.

Our recommendation
Choose materials based on the building's needs, not a blanket claim that one roof is always
best. Reliant Roofing installs both asphalt and metal systems in Central Minnesota and can
walk you through appearance, installation details, expected maintenance, and total project
cost.
Reliant Roofing | Finally, a contractor you can rely on.